Evaluation of a Job Offer

Andy Reynolds

Key Takeaways – When reviewing an opportunity to take a new job or leave a W2 salary to start a business, the following considerations must be made.


  • What are all the aspects of my compensation package? This includes salary and other benefits such as insurance, retirement, and other fringe benefits.
  • Most health insurance policies are established through employers. Does the new opportunity have a health insurance plan?  If so, does the plan meet your needs for a reasonable price?  If not, how will you obtain health insurance?
  • Considering all benefits and net income changes, is the job change significantly beneficial – monetarily, culturally, and professionally – to make a change to your current situation?


When we bring on a new client, one of the first commitments we make to them is to be another smart brain at the table, helping to objectively evaluate any and all financial decisions.  This can vary across many different topics such as refinancing a mortgage, to helping discuss the terms of a business sale, to reviewing a budget, to the finances of purchasing a new pet.  One specific item that we really want to spend time on before a decision is made is when a new job offer is being considered.


In today’s work environment jobs are taking on all sorts of shapes and sizes.  Some people have a your typical W2 salary, more and more are becoming independent contractors, and even more have some type of side hustle.  According to a 2019 survey by Bankrate.com1, nearly 45% of Americans reported having additional income outside of their primary job.  And these jobs are not insignificant.  The average person is working an additional 12 hours per week and earning an additional $1,122 per month.  With continued technological advancements benefiting small business owners, we are seeing more and more people fostering their employment skills or their side hustle opportunities into new businesses where they are both the employer and the employee.


So, what does someone need to know when considering a new job or when considering leaving their job with benefits to go off on their own?  To simplify this commentary, I solely focused on an employee seeking a new job opportunity.  However, a similar process can be used when considering leaving the comfort of a W2 position and starting your own enterprise, but self-employment taxes and business deductible expenses must also be considered.


Great Job, Inc. vs. Opportunity, Inc.


Edward is a fictitious character who is an IT Specialist.  Edward has a W2 position at Great Job, Inc. and is considering a new job as a Supervisor at Opportunity, Inc.  Edward makes $80,000 per year and is immediately attracted to a new job offer at $100,000 per year, “An extra $20,000 per year!  That’s a 25% increase in pay!!he thought.  Before Edward makes the leap, he is wise enough to call his trusted Financial Advocate at Ballast, who identifies the following: Edward failed to take into consideration the benefits that he has at his current employer.  Many benefits are paid for by Great Job, Inc., but Opportunity, Inc. does not pay for any benefits, other than his salary.  See the chart below.


Great Job, Inc. Opportunity, Inc.
Income $80,000 $100,000
Health, Dental, Vision Insurance PAID FOR -$6,000
Disability Insurance PAID FOR -$2,400
401(k) Match (6%) PAID FOR -$4,800* *6% of $80,000
Cell Phone PAID FOR -$1,800
HSA ($2,000/Yr.) PAID FOR -$2,000
Professional Development PAID FOR -$3,000
Income After Expenses $80,000 $80,000


In Edward’s example above, it is clear to see that the benefits that a company offers plays a significant role in the total “compensation” a person receives.  Unfortunately for Edward, the new opportunity above is even slightly less favorable because not all the deductions from Opportunity Inc. would qualify as a pre-tax deduction.


All employer paid benefits need to be acknowledged when considering a new employer, considering making your side hustle full-time, or if one is considering taking their skill set from an employee to an independent contractor.


So, if you are looking for a job or are offered a job, how do you proceed?  We have created the process below to help objectively evaluate the opportunity.


How to Analyze a New Opportunity?


1. Review all the benefits that you receive up and above salary and create a chart comparing the two different job opportunities. Mark any benefit that is not included adequately from both companies as deductible or non-deductible from an income tax perspective.

2. Estimate your out of pocket costs for the benefits that are not included from one company to the other.

3. Consider the NET, after-tax income you would receive from each company.

4. Review Insurance Coverages. How do the coverages compare, especially health insurance?  Do both plans meet you and your family’s needs?

5. Review the important intangibles.

a.The culture and the people within each organization.
b. The opportunity to grow within the organization.
c. The opportunity for career development.
d. Paid time off.
e. Flexibility of the workday.


STEP 1 Job 1 Job 2 Deductible?
All Insurances YES YES N/A
Retirement (6%) YES NO YES
HSA ($2,000/Year) YES NO YES
Cell Phone Provided YES NO NO
Professional Development? YES NO NO



STEPS 2 & 3 Job 1 Job 2
Salary $75,000 $90,000
Retirement Catch Up ($4,500)
Health Savings Account ($2,000)
PRE-TAX INCOME $75,000 $83,500
Federal ($5,739) ($6,759)
FICA ($5,739) ($6,388)
State ($3,624) ($4,049)
Local ($2,063) ($2,296)
NET $57,835 $64,008
Less Non-Deductible Cell Phone ($1,800)
Less Non-Deductible Development ($750)
NET, NET Income Estimate $57,835 $61,458
*Taxes estimated by https://smartasset.com/taxes/income-taxes, in Lexington, KY


Making a job change is a very important decision.  Studies show that most Americans will change jobs three to seven times during their lifetime.  This tool will help one analyze the true opportunity within a new job opportunity.  As always, we want to be part of the decision-making process, please do not hesitate to contact us and ask for our thoughts.  We are always here to help.



1 Dixon, Amanda; Survey: Nearly 1 in 3 side hustlers needs the income to stay afloat; Bankrate; June 5, 2019; https://www.bankrate.com/personal-finance/side-hustles-survey-june-2019/